The ROI of Hardfacing | Midwest Hardfacing

What Is Hardfacing and How Does It Work?

Hardfacing is a specialized welding technique that lays down a tough, wear‑resistant layer of material onto machinery parts that face heavy abrasion or impact. Instead of letting equipment components—like roller mill rings, hammer mill hammers, or crusher liners—wear down and require complete replacement, you simply reinforce their surfaces with an alloy designed to stand up to harsh conditions.

The Basics of the Process

The procedure begins with a thorough cleaning of the worn surface to remove rust, oil, and debris. Technicians then apply a hardfacing alloy—tungsten carbide, for example—using welding methods such as stick or MIG overlay, or more advanced processes like Plasma Transferred Arc (PTA). Once cooled, the new layer bonds metallurgically to the base metal, creating a protective shield against continuing wear.

Reducing Wear and Tear

By proactively building up surfaces before they fail, hardfacing prevents the deep grooves, cracks, and thinning that lead to emergency downtime. Roller mill rings stay at the right diameter longer, maintaining grind efficiency. Hammer mill tips hold their profile, ensuring consistent impact energy. Across any heavy‑wear part, hardfacing slows the wear cycle—so you replace or reapply coatings on your own schedule, not in reaction to a breakdown.

Understanding the ROI of Hardfacing: Why It’s a Smart Investment?

Calculating return on investment (ROI) for hardfacing is straightforward once you compare the costs of preventive maintenance against those of reactive repairs and part replacements. The basic formula is:

ROI = (Savings from Maintenance – Cost of Maintenance) ÷ Cost of Maintenance

Preventive Costs vs. Emergency Expenses

Consider a hammer mill that chews through abrasive feedstock. If you wait until hammers are so worn they shatter, you’ll face a full set of new hammers at, say, $12,000, plus rush shipping and overtime labor—easily $15,000 total. In contrast, a scheduled hardfacing touch‑up might run $2,500 and be completed during planned downtime. That’s an immediate savings of over $12,000, before you even factor in the cost of lost production.

Long‑Term Savings Compound Quickly

Hardfacing doesn’t just save you money once—it keeps saving each time you follow your preventive schedule. Suppose you hardface your roller mill rings annually for $5,000. Without hardfacing, you’d replace them every 18 months at $20,000 apiece. Over five years, preventive maintenance costs total $25,000 versus $60,000 in replacement costs—netting a $35,000 saving. That’s an ROI of 140%.

Intangible Benefits Boost the ROI of Hardfacing Further

Reduced Downtime Risk: Planned maintenance windows avoid unpredictable stoppages that can halt multiple production lines.
Improved Process Consistency: Equipment that wears predictably maintains quality and throughput, safeguarding revenue and customer satisfaction.
Lower Inventory Carrying Costs: Fewer emergency parts on the shelf frees capital for other operational needs.

When you put these numbers on paper, the case for hardfacing becomes crystal clear. You’re investing in fewer interruptions, lower replacement costs, and steadier production—all of which drive substantial financial gains over time.

Ready to see hardfacing’s impact on your maintenance budget? Learn more about our rebuilding services and discover how our tungsten‑carbide solutions can extend your equipment’s life.

Explore Rebuilding

Comparing Costs: Hardfacing vs. Traditional Repairs and Replacements

When you stack up the numbers, hardfacing often wins hands down over conventional part rebuilding or replacement. Let’s break down the cost categories:

Upfront Investment

A full replacement of roller mill rings can set you back $20,000, while a scheduled hardfacing overlay on those same rings typically costs $4,000–$6,000. Even accounting for labor and setup, you’re spending less than a third of the replacement price—and you’re reusing perfectly good core components.

Ongoing Maintenance

Without hardfacing, a set of hammer mill hammers might require replacement every six months, each costing $10,000 in parts and installation. By contrast, a hardfacing refresh applied annually at $2,500 extends their life beyond twelve months. Over a three‑year span, you’d pay $60,000 in reactive replacements versus $7,500 for preventive hardfacing—plus you avoid multiple rounds of rush shipping and emergency labor rates.

Downtime and Productivity Loss

Emergency repairs often mean full‑shift stoppages. If your operation normally earns $5,000 in production value per hour, losing four hours for an unplanned hammer replacement racks up $20,000 in lost revenue. A planned hardfacing job might take the same interval but is already built into your maintenance calendar, so you avoid surprise stoppages and keep production forecasts on target.

Industries That Benefit Most from Hardfacing ROI

Almost any operation with heavy‑wear equipment can see substantial savings, but here are a few standout examples:

Construction

Excavator buckets and dozer blades face daily abrasion from rock, gravel, and soil. Hardfacing these edges cuts down on blade replacements—often required every six months—saving upwards of $25,000 per machine annually.

Mining

Crushers, hoppers, and conveyor components grind against ore and stone. Reactive replacements in a mid‑sized mine can total $200,000 a year. A hardfacing program trims that by more than 70%, freeing capital for expansion rather than spare‑parts inventory.

Agriculture

Plowshares, combine blades, and tillage tools endure tough soil and crop residue. Farmers report that hardfacing extends tool life from one growing season to three, cutting maintenance costs by over 60% and keeping harvest schedules on track.

Manufacturing

High‑speed rollers and punch presses take constant impact. In a stamping plant, unscheduled downtime for die replacements can cost $10,000 per hour in lost output. Hardfacing dies and supporting rollers reduces downtime by half, translating to $100,000+ saved per year.

Maximizing the ROI of Your Hardfacing: Best Practices

To turn hardfacing into a true profit driver, follow these key practices:

Schedule by Actual Wear, Not a Calendar

Track run hours and wear indicators—such as coating thickness or small surface cracks—to set maintenance intervals that match real‑world use.

Choose the Right Alloy

Match the material to your specific wear profile. Tungsten carbide excels in high‑abrasion settings, while nickel‑based alloys resist both abrasion and chemical attack. A material that’s a perfect fit will last far longer and avoid premature failures.

Maintain Detailed Records

Log the date, cost, materials used, and performance of every hardfacing job. Analyzing this data helps you refine intervals, tweak material choices, and prove ROI to stakeholders.

Partner with Experts

Work with a seasoned hardfacing provider who can recommend optimal alloys, apply advanced techniques (like Plasma Transferred Arc), and train your team on inspection and minor touch‑ups.

By integrating these best practices into your preventive maintenance program, you’ll not only lower costs but also build a scalable strategy that grows with your operation.

Improve Your ROI With Midwest Hardfacing

Hardfacing isn’t just a repair—it’s a powerful investment that pays dividends in reduced replacement costs, minimized downtime, and extended machinery life. By comparing preventive hardfacing to traditional repairs and replacements, you can see clearly how the numbers work in your favor.

If you’re ready to put real numbers behind your hardfacing strategy, contact Midwest Hardfacing today for a personalized ROI and hardfacing analysis and discover how preventive hardfacing maintenance can become your most effective cost‑saving measure.